We are a local Real Estate Company representing buyers & sellers. Specializing in residential, investment, short sale, bank owned properties and property management.

Top Services

Key Reasons Why You Should Choose Olinger & Co.


Comprehensive Real Estate Services

Olinger & Co offers a wide range of real estate services, including buying, selling, and renting properties. Whether you are a first-time homebuyer, an experienced investor, or looking to sell your property, they have the expertise and resources to assist you every step of the way.If you are in need of a reliable and experienced real estate brokerage in Coshocton, Ohio, Olinger & Co is the name to trust. Contact them today to schedule a consultation and experience their exceptional service firsthand.


Best Customer Satisfaction

Christi Olinger and Olinger & Co have received numerous positive reviews from satisfied clients. Their professionalism, knowledge, and dedication to client satisfaction have earned them a stellar reputation in the industry. You can have confidence in their ability to deliver exceptional results.


Personalized Approach

At Olinger & Co, they believe in delivering personalized service tailored to each client's unique needs and goals. They take the time to listen and understand your requirements, ensuring that you receive the attention and support you deserve throughout the entire real estate transaction.


Honesty and Integrity

Olinger & Co prides itself on its commitment to honesty and integrity. They prioritize the best interests of their clients and strive to maintain transparent and open communication throughout the process. You can trust that they will provide you with accurate information and guide you towards making informed decisions.


Best Price and Offer

At Olinger & Co, we are dedicated to helping our clients achieve the best price and offer when buying or selling a property. With our market knowledge, strategic pricing, and negotiation expertise, we work to maximize your investment. Trust us to guide you through the process with integrity and personalized service.


Extensive Experience

With over 18 years of experience in the industry, Christi Olinger and her team at Olinger & Co have a deep understanding of the local real estate market. They have successfully helped numerous clients buy, sell, and rent properties, including residential, investment, short sale, and bank-owned properties.

Our Current Listings

MLS Search

Meet Our Team


Christi Olinger

My number one priority has always been my client! As a licensed real estate Broker it is my goal to assist my clients through their real estate deal with honesty and integrity. I have lived in Coshocton County since

before I had children and now my children are raising their children here in Coshocton County. I will work hard to earn your trust and with my 24/7 never quit work ethic YOU will have me guiding you through the real estate process from start to finish.


Anita Angelo

I have teamed up with Olinger & Company Realty for the Property Management Division. With 12 years Real Estate experience, 5 years rental property experience, as well as 1yr experience working with a local real estate attorney I am providing the company and its clients with prompt, professional, and knowledgeable experience.

We proudly offer our clients services that includes our broker, multiple property managers, and a bookkeeper to insure prompt service and reporting to our clients.

Please contact us to arrange a time that is convenient for you either over the phone or in person to discuss your current needs and your future plans for growth of your rental properties.


Catherine Marlatt

Although I was 5 years old when my family moved back to Newcomerstown, I have always considered myself a native of this warm and growing community! I have been licensed since 2019 and have helped folks find their first, second, and their forever homes in Tuscarawas and many of the surrounding counties.I am a mom to two wonderful children, Blade who is 21 and 17 year old Gunner, and have been active in the local school system for many years. In my free time I enjoy gardening, being a part of several community groups, and helping folks find their "happy place". I love to travel, hike new properties, and am always ready to help folks buying or selling anywhere in Ohio!


Tina Hardesty

I’ve always tried to be a helper. In high school I was a member of Teachers of Tomorrow and gave up my study hall to walk to the elementary or junior high to help younger students and teachers. For over 15 years I helped customers choose their movies or games at Video Express at either the West Lafayette or Newcomerstown locations. I volunteered as a band mom for Ridgewood for many years, have volunteered at the food pantry in Coshocton and my daughters and I have served on two church mission trips. For the past 23 years I worked with and helped students in all programs at the Career Center. Becoming a realtor seems a natural progression for me as a helper. I want to assist friends, family and future clients in buying a new home or selling their current home. Real estate has been a dream of mine since we closed the video store. I looked into it then, but was not able to devote the time required for classes. Now, after much hard work, I am so happy and proud to finally be a licensed real estate agent, knowledgeable of the latest real estate laws and practices. I would love for you and your family to be the next people that I am fortunate enough to help.


Halie Schwab

Hello, Im Halie! Being a Ridgewood graduate and a Fresno local my whole life I’m excited to serve you as your local agent. My passion is making people’s home dreams come true by getting you into your next house. My hobbies include going on vacations to warmer places and being a dog mom to my Shiba Inu, Kia . I can’t wait to serve you and my community by being your local real estate agent. Call me for all your real estate needs.


Contact us by filling out the form below.

Contact Us

I agree to terms & conditions provided by the Olinger & Company Realty. By clicking submit, you agree to receive email, text, and/or voice updates. Carrier fees may apply.

Office: 687 Hill St. Coshocton, OH 43812

Call: (740) 224-8624

Email: ChristiOlinger@gmail.com

ALL Right Reserved. Copyright 2023.

Website Design by Hasseman Marketing.